Introduction to piston design for forced induction engines

Introduction to piston design for forced induction engines

June 28, 2010

By 

There are many great articles online on general piston design, piston ring design, and how the design of OEM and aftermarket pistons has changed over the last decade.

 

What we will focus on today is the choice of a proper aftermarket piston for your street engine running a significant amount of forced induction using supercharged, turbocharged, nitrous injected or a combination of these power adders.

So what we have in mind today is a daily driven motor, running in the rpm range up to about 8000 rpms with up to 18psi of boost pressure, and experience all the typical operating conditions of a daily driven motor including cold starts, short warm up durations, conventional oiling systems …etc

Before we start talking about piston design I want to first spend a minute talking about the different sections of the piston that are of interest:

The Crown: Is the top most surface of the piston which creates the moving bottom barrier in the combustion chamber. This part of the piston is in contact with incoming airflow, burnt exhaust gasses, and is part of the combustion chamber shape.

The Ring lands: Are the reliefs cut into the side profile of the piston where the piston rings sit. The ring lands are typically taller than the ring thickness which allows the rings to move and rotate in the bore. It also allows combustion pressure to contact the entire piston ring top face inside the ringland pressing it down (and out in some designs) improving ring seal.

The Skirt: The piston skirt is the extension of the side profile of piston which controls the piston movement in the bore preventing it from wobbling around and controlling the angular forces present on the piston walls from the angular rotation of the crankshaft.

The Underside: This part of the piston is exposed to the crank case and houses the wrist pin (connecting the piston to the rod) and exposed to the engine oil in 3 ways:

  • Oil collected by the oil retention ring (the bottom most piston ring) is routed through holes in the side of the piston to the underside to drain back into the crank case.
  • Oil sloshing around in the crankcase due to the crankshaft counterweights dipping in and out of the oil sump as well as oil forced up through the connecting rod up to lubricate the wrist pin (on forced oil pins).
  • On engines equipped with oil squirters under the piston, where oil is squirted on the underside to help cool the piston mass for longevity or racing applications, which in some situations may also allow for an overall thinner crown without sacrificing the strength of the piston and while reducing the overall weight of the package.

When it comes to choosing the right pistons for your street car on boost there are five aspects to look into:

1- Construction
2- Design
3- Coatings
4- Other considerations

1- Piston Construction:

For a street driven application, you’re looking for primarily a forged piston with a high silicone content in the range of 12% to 16%. The high silicone content in the piston improves thermal management in the piston and reduces the overall expansion of the piston in the bore when heated due to boost and power.

This reduced expansion means that you will not need to use undersized pistons (that will grow to fill the bore as they heat up) and engine will not have large tolerances causing piston slap at cold starts and long warm ups in cold weather, which is ideal for street applications.

Furthermore, most modern engines come with high volumetric efficiency from the factory (for example the new mustang 5.0 engine in 2011 will come with 412hp stock compared to a much lower 165 to 205hp -depending on the actual model year for the older 1980s ford 5.0).

Having engines now producing roughly double the power that they were producing just 15 years ago, and having the potential of further doubling that power figure with nitrous injection or 15psi of supercharged boost, then care must be taken to making sure the piston ring lands are anodized for reduced micro-welding between the piston and its rings under the increased heat and pressures from forced induction.

2- Piston Design:

As mentioned earlier, the top of the piston (the crown) is both exposed to the incoming airflow, as well as constitutes the bottom of the combustion chamber.

The piston crown during the intake stroke :To take swirl one step further, certain piston manufacturers have equipped their pistons with swirl enhancing crown faces either equipped with circular grooves or dimpled impressions on the piston crown. These groves and dimples are designed to promote increased swirl in street engines and have been shown to further improve torque delivery by another 4 to 5% over stock figures. Similarly, high compression pistons that gain compression through a very sharp protrusion in the center of the piston will reduce disrupt swirl in the chamber and lower combustion efficiency, although the increase in compression (at 3 to 4% per added point of compression) can negate this loss.

 

high swirl engines continue to tumble the air inside the bore

high swirl engines continue to tumble the air inside the bore

 

dimpled top pistons

Dimpled top pistons and groove top pistons improve airflow swirl and tumbling

 

 

Custom made dimpled top pistons for similar effect

Custom machined dimpled top pistons for similar effect

piston squish

 

 

Not all cylinder heads are hemi(spherical) heads. In this application for example a piston with a kidney shaped dish and a raised outer edge will give better results than a flat or symmetrical hemi-style piston

Not all cylinder heads are hemi(spherical) heads. In this application for example a piston with a kidney shaped dish and a raised outer edge will give better results than a flat or symmetrical hemi-style piston

Asymmetrical piston for a hemi head, notice the lip that goes around the entire out rim of the piston to squish air towards the central spark plug

Asymmetrical piston for a hemi head, notice the lip that goes around the entire out rim of the piston to squish air towards the central spark plug

 

combustion profile

Combustion profile showing the irregular distance between the spark plug and the edges of the boundaries combustion chamber on a typical flat top piston

 

piston cutaway showing the distance between the valve relief and the first ring land which should be maintained at 0.2"

piston cutaway showing the distance between the valve relief and the first ring land which should be maintained at 0.2″

 

 

If you’ve never seen a piston machined down before … watch this video:

 

visible here: piston crown with thermal barrier coating, side skirt with friction reduction coating, forced side relief (FSR) piston with reduced side skirts for very high rpm operation (typical on race engines and motorcycles)

visible here: piston crown with thermal barrier coating, side skirt with friction reduction coating, forced side relief (FSR) piston with reduced side skirts for very high rpm operation (typical on race engines and motorcycles)

 

 

visible here: bottom of the piston with oil shedding coating

visible here: bottom of the piston with oil shedding coating

 

For more information on tuning your engine for a high-cycle lifetime of abuse... be sure to checkout The Tuner Mastermind

 

The piston crown during the compression stroke :

 

This brings us to a very important point which is engine ‘squish’. The use of asymmetcrical piston crown design not only continues the swirl process initiated in the intake system, but more importantly having an asymmetrical piston crown forces the air to rapildy move towards one side of the combustion chamber, especially as the piston approaches top dead center. This squish effect near top dead center can be used for several advantages:

  1. Getting a good air and fuel mix for more efficient combustion.
  2. Moving the air and fuel mixture closer to the spark plug for easier ignition.
  3. Reducing the distance between the tip of the spark plug, and the farthest pocket of air and fuel mixture that needs to be burnt. Reducing the flame front travel distance builds cylinder pressure faster in the chamber which reduces timing advance requirements at lower rpms, but also, maintains more torque delivery to the piston as rpms increase (and as the time that the piston spends between top dead center and 17* ATDC) starts to shrink rapidly compared to flame front travel speed past a certain rpm point, as well as for engines with a shorter rod to stroke ratio with faster piston acceleration away from Top Dead Center.
  4. Reducing the probability of detonation and uneven combustion from the better air and fuel mixture and better heat distribution.
Knowing these advantages during the compression stroke to shaping the piston top, then the typical flat top pistons of late become obviously obsolete. The best piston choice is actually a D shaped ‘reverse dome’ piston which combines an asymmetrical crown design with a thicker crown height that either mirrors the combustion chamber shape (as seen look into the bottom of the cylinder head) or with a thicker out ring on hemispherical head. The whole point here is that the air fuel charge is compressed in a tighter pocket area around the spark plug location, and moved away from the far cylinder walls. Then, to maintain the same compression ratio (even with this thicker crown height) the crown area around the spark plug is dished by the right amount to bring the total volume of the combustion chamber + the piston dish to be the correct volume for the proper engine compression ratio.

 

Furthermore, on some applications we can take this one step further by milling down the cylinder head (or using a different cylinder head casting with shallower combustion chambers) which brings the spark plug down deeper into the bore, and offsetting the loss of combustion chamber volume with further dish in the piston crown. Bringing the air and fuel pocket closer to the spark plug, and bringing the spark plug closer to the center of the combustion chamber formed between the cylinder head contours and the piston crown contours boost engine efficiency, reduces detonation probability, reduces timing advance requirements, and promotes increased efficiencies at higher rpms as described earlier.

Finally, for a forced induced motor, care must be taken that the crown thickness after all modifications to the piston crown are complete (such as enlarging the valve reliefs for oversized valves, or increasing the piston dish for a shallower cylinder head and a lower spark plug position as described earlier) is still at least 0.175” thick with a good margin of safety being around the 0.200” mark for forged aftermarket pistons. Another thing to note is that typically enlarging valve reliefs not only reduces crown thickness as a vertical measurement, but also diagonally reduces the distance between the valve relief and the primary piston ring. This is even more evident on newer high efficinecy (low emissions) engines that come from the factory with a raised primary compression piston ring (or a reduced distance / lip between the piston top and the first ring land).To summarize:

 

When choosing an aftermarket piston for your motor, look for a reverse dome piston top (rather than a flat top or typical dish type piston) with dimpled flat surfaces for better mixture, and still having at least 0.2” material thickness throughout the entire crown of the piston.

If the piston I just described does not exist, a thick piston (high compression) piston can be machined down to make the piston I’m describing by someone who knows enough about this to do it properly (or by requesting a custom style piston from the piston manufacturer themselves).

3- Piston Coatings

Investing the money in getting your pistons coated has several benefits including:

  • Increased power
  • Reduced emissions
  • Better response
  • More resistance to catastrophic failure

The best combination of coatings are as follows:

  • A thermal barrier coating on the piston crown
  • A friction reduction coating on the piston skirts
  • An oil shedding coating on engines equipped with oil squirters in the crank case

The thermal barrier coating gives a more consistent finish to the top of the piston crown. It helps reflect heat into the combustion chamber, rather than dissipating it through the piston materials and thus improves combustion speed and the completeness of the combustion process. However, this increase in combustion temps and trapping the power rather than dissipating it does require reduced timing advance, but will as stated earlier, pay back dividends on higher rpm motors or on engines with short rod/stroke ratios where piston acceleration away from TDC becomes a problem for power transfer into the pistons at higher rpms.

One thing to note here is that since the thermal barrier coating improves torque delivery by accelerating the burn rate inside the engine, it can be used to boost torque output on cars with centrifugal superchargers or large turbos to give better response before the boost builds.

Overall, it may seem like it’s disadvantageous to trap more heat in the chamber and that it possibly reduces the octane, boost, or timing limits of the motor but this is not true. The increased heat can be counteracted with timing reduction without power loss (since the burn rate is maintained) and the added advantages are that the thermal coating helps spread the heat out over the entire crown area of the piston, thus protecting any thin or weak spots from being pummeled to failure. Also in the rare event that you do have some minor detonation in the engine due to high load, a bad fill of gas, or some other factors, the thermal coating prevents piston pitting due to minor occurrences of detonation, and thus it prevents the creation of hot spots on the piston crown which could have become hot-beds for further detonation and a prevented runaway towards total piston failure!

Seems like a fair trade off of some timing advance for increased longevity and increased high rpm efficiency.

The low friction coating on the piston skirt reduces frictional losses between the piston sides and the cylinder walls. This protects the pistons from damage and scuffing on cold starts, if the engine is overheated or overboosted (and the piston expands due to heat), and during oil starvation conditions (high cornering G’s, coild oil, first crank after a rebuild).

Reducing friction in the engine delivers more horsepower to the crank, improves the engine’s operation near redline, and gives the engine crisper response. One study showed that using lower profile skirts, with proper friction coating, as well as lower friction wrist pins can reduce the total engine internal friction by 40%…

So, something as simple and non intrusive as coating your piston skirts is definitly worth the effort, especially on boosted street cars that need to run a full skirted piston (as opposed to naturally aspirated motorcycles that will more likely run a forced side relief piston which features a longer skirt in the primary axis of the piston motion as the connecting rod movement shoves and pulls the piston against the bore on the upwards and downwards strokes… and a short or no-skirt in the axis 90* with plane of the connecting rod’s movement).

Finally, oil shedding coatings on the bottom surface of the piston help evacuate oil off of the piston faster. This helps keep the piston lighter and faster moving in its rotation, however since oil is used to cool the piston bottom and increase its longevity (especially in motors that will experience high cycles as we will explain later), then there is a debate as to weather this coating is beneficial or detrimental on different engines.

Engines with oil squirters get plenty of oil volume delivered to the bottom of the piston at a constant stream of flow. These engines can do with a reduced duration for oil clinging to the bottom of the piston.

On the other hand engines that rely on the crankshaft counterweights sloshing in the oil sump and indirectly sending oil up to the pistons to cool them (and up to the wrist pins to lubricate them on engines without a force-lubricated style connecting rod) could use with the oil clinging to the piston bottom for a longer duration.

If you are doing a full rebuild, my recommendation would be to both coat your pistons AND install oil squirters. Otherwise, choose weather or not to use the oil shedding coating based on weather you have a dry sump, wet sump with squirters, or wet sump without squirters oiling system.

4- Other Piston Design Considerations

As mentioned earlier there are other considerations to choosing your piston design which I have eluded to earlier.

Even though most people judge engine life based on mileage, performance engines are more accurately judged on cycles.

For example, an engine can run for 100 continuous miles at 7500 rpms in 1st gear, or at 1500 rpms in 5th gear…. the same engine could be tracked every weekend (spending a healthy portion of its life in the higher rpm ranges) or cruised on a highyway commute to and from work.

Even though these two engines have the same mileage, they have lived through a different number of engine cycles. Engine cycles is what determines the amount of continuous (or accumulated) stress both on your pistons (for thermal management) as well as on your piston rings (for wear management).

The advice given here is primarily for dual purpose vehicles that are both street cars but will see occasional or repeated track use.

Vehicles that will be used primarily for racing, require a thicker crown for better thermal management, will probably use a lower silicone content piston (with much larger piston to bore clearances to allow for the thermal expansion of the piston after it stops slapping and warms up in the bore, and will definitely have lower ring height for the primary compression ring (which reduces the operating temperature of the ring from around 600*F to around 300*F) as well as using a thicker compression ring that is less likely to distort or fail under continuous sustained high rpm abuse (think about a car in Nascar racing that does the entire race over 5000 rpms…)

These cars that are designed for ‘standing mile races’ as I like to call them or long term endurance racing will also have to be tune differently as I have a complete longevity tuning chapter in The Tuner Mastermind.

However, for most street vehicles running up to around 18psi of boost, and having dual street / track duty… then follow exactly the piston recommendations detailed here and you will have a great combination of torque, efficiency, detonation resistance, and reliability.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *